Guide6 min readUpdated
How to Evaluate a Designer Portfolio: Guide for Non-Designers
Learn how to evaluate a designer portfolio even if you are not a designer: what to look for in case studies, how to test the work, and what to ask.
Suppose you run a tiffin service in Durgapur and you want an ordering app. You open three designer portfolios. All three look polished. You cannot tell which one to trust. This guide gives you a simple way to evaluate a designer portfolio without any design training.
A design portfolio is a collection of a designer's past projects, shown with enough detail that you can judge how the designer thinks and works. The word "thinks" matters. Anyone can make a screen look nice. Fewer people can explain why a button sits where it does.
Case study or pretty screens: which tells you more?
A case study tells you far more than a gallery of screens. A case study explains the problem, the designer's role, the steps taken and what changed. A gallery only shows the final surface.
Pretty screens can come from a template, from a copied style or from an AI tool. A case study is harder to fake, because it needs real decisions. When you open a project, ask three plain questions:
- What problem was this product trying to solve?
- What exactly did this designer do, and what did someone else do?
- What did they decide, and what did they reject?
If a project answers none of these, treat it as a picture, not as proof. Pictures are fine for a first look. They are weak evidence for a hiring decision.
What should a UI UX portfolio show?
A good UI UX portfolio shows the whole journey of a product, not only the last step. UI means the screens a person sees. UX means how the product works for that person. You can read more in UI vs UX design explained.
Look for these items in each case study:
- A short statement of the problem and who the users were.
- The flow: how a person moves from the first screen to the goal.
- Rough sketches or wireframes, which are simple black and white layouts before colour.
- The final interface, with more than the home screen.
- Notes on a hard decision, such as why a form was split into two steps.
- A clear line about the designer's role and the time taken.
A designer who only shows final screens may still be good. You then need to ask for the missing parts on a call. The stages of a mobile app design process show what you can expect to see.
How can a non-designer judge the work itself?
You can judge the work by testing it against real situations, because real products face messy conditions. You do not need design vocabulary for these checks. Try them on any screen in the portfolio.
- The squint test. Blur your eyes. Can you still see the one main action on the screen? If five things shout at once, the screen has no priority.
- The text test. Read every label. Do they say exactly what will happen? "Submit" is weaker than "Place order".
- The long name test. Imagine a customer named Rajeshwari Chattopadhyay. Would the name fit? Imagine Bengali or Hindi text. Does the layout survive?
- The bad day test. Look for a screen that shows an error, an empty list or a slow network. A designer who thinks about these screens has built real products. See empty, loading and error screens.
- The small phone test. Open the portfolio on your own phone. Most users in India are on mid-range Android phones. Are the buttons easy to tap with a thumb?
- The consistency test. Do buttons, spacing and colours stay the same across ten screens?
None of these tests needs a degree. They need only patience and one honest look.
How do you check that the work is really theirs?
You check by asking the designer to walk you through one project in their own words. Real authors remember details. They know what was cut, what the client disliked and what changed after testing.
Ask these questions on a call:
- Which screen took the longest, and why?
- What did the client or developer push back on?
- If you started again, what would you change?
- Which part was done by someone else?
Listen for specific answers, such as "we moved the verification step after the first listing, because sellers were leaving at the start". A vague answer such as "we focused on user experience" tells you little. A long list of tools without a story is also a weak sign. The questions to ask a UI UX designer before hiring go deeper.
Copied work is a real risk. If a style looks like a famous app, search for that app and compare. Similar patterns are normal, because many apps share common layouts. Identical screens with a different logo are not normal.
Does a small portfolio or NDA work mean a weak designer?
No. A small portfolio can come from a new designer, and an NDA can hide strong work. An NDA is a non-disclosure agreement, a promise not to show a client's private product. Many founders ask designers to keep work private, and a designer who respects that deserves some credit.
Handle these cases fairly:
- Ask whether any project can be shown in a private walkthrough on Google Meet.
- Ask for a small paid trial task, such as one screen or one flow, with a clear price.
- Look at how the designer explains projects that are public.
- Check the match to your kind of product, not only the total number of projects.
A newer designer with two honest case studies can serve you better than a famous name who hands your project to someone else. A bigger team may suit you if you need many people at once. That choice is covered in freelance designer vs design agency.
A 15 minute portfolio check you can do today
You can run a fair check in 15 minutes with the table below. Score each row as yes, partly or no for each designer you consider.
| Question | What a good answer looks like |
|---|---|
| Is there work similar to mine? | A project in your domain or with similar users, such as a marketplace or a booking flow |
| Is the problem explained? | One clear paragraph before any screen |
| Is the designer's role stated? | Words like "I designed" with the scope named |
| Are hard screens shown? | Errors, empty states, forms, settings |
| Is the work consistent? | Same buttons, spacing and colours across screens |
| Does it work on a small phone? | Readable text and large tap areas |
| Can they explain one decision? | A reason linked to a user or a business limit |
Do not expect a perfect score. A designer with five yes answers and two partly answers is usually worth a conversation.
What about my own taste?
Your taste matters, but it is not the test. You may like a bold style that does not suit your users. A coaching institute with parents as visitors needs a calm and clear page, not a trend. Ask whether the designer chose a style because of the users or because of habit.
What to do after the portfolio check
After the check, shortlist two or three designers and send each the same short brief. A written brief makes replies easier to compare. The guide to writing a design brief will help. Then compare how each person responds. Good designers ask questions before quoting.
For reference, I have designed more than 20 products since 2021, including a seller app for a marketplace in Tanzania where I designed onboarding, verification and listings. You can judge that kind of work yourself in my portfolio using the tests above.
Frequently asked questions
How many projects should a designer portfolio have?
+
There is no fixed number. Two or three well explained case studies are more useful than twenty screens with no story. Look for depth and for a project close to your own.
Can I trust a portfolio that has only final screens?
+
You can trust it as a first look, not as proof. Ask the designer to explain the problem, the steps and one hard decision on a call before you decide.
Should I ask a designer for a free sample?
+
Free work is hard to ask for fairly, because design takes real time. A small paid trial, such as one screen or one flow, gives you a real sample and keeps the relationship fair.
How can I tell if a designer copied a design?
+
Search for the app that the style resembles and compare screen by screen. Shared patterns are common. Identical layouts, icons and wording are a warning.
Working on something like this?
Tell Tithi what you are planning. You get a clear scope, a fixed price and a timeline before any work begins. I reply to every enquiry within 24 hours.