Tithi MondalBlog

Article6 min readUpdated

Custom Icon Design vs Icon Libraries: Which to Choose

Custom icon design or a free icon library? See when a library is enough, when a custom icon set for your app pays off, and how grid and stroke work.

Read inहिन्दीবাংলাमराठीதமிழ்తెలుగుગુજરાતી

Custom Icon Design vs Icon Libraries: Which to Choose: cover illustration

Imagine a grocery delivery app for a town like Siliguri. The founder sends me twelve screens. The cart icon is thick and rounded. The location pin is thin and sharp. The profile icon is filled, and the orders icon is only an outline. Each icon came from a different free source, and each one is fine alone. Together they look like four different apps.

This is the real question behind "custom icons or a library". It is not about quality. It is about whether your icons look like they belong to one product. A free icon library is enough for many apps. A custom icon design is worth paying for in a few specific cases. This post explains how to tell which case you are in.

When a free icon library is enough

A free icon library gives you hundreds of icons in one consistent style. If you pick one library and use only that library, you already have icon style consistency. That is the most important point in this post.

A library is usually enough in these cases:

  • You are building a first version and need to launch in a few weeks.
  • Your app uses common actions: home, search, cart, profile, settings, notifications, back, close.
  • Your brand is still changing, so a custom set might be redrawn in six months.
  • Your budget is small and the money is better spent on the main screens.
  • Your admin panel or internal tool is used by staff, not customers.

Many good products use a library for years. The library's icons are well tested, drawn on a proper grid and available in several weights. Most of them also come as SVG icons, which I explain below.

Two cautions. First, check the licence of any free icon library before you use it in a commercial app. Licences differ, and some need a credit line. Second, do not mix libraries. Taking the cart from one and the bell from another is exactly how the Siliguri example happened.

When a custom icon set is worth it

A custom icon set earns its cost when icons carry meaning that a library cannot supply. Think about three situations.

Your product has its own concepts. A library has a cart, but it has no icon for "tiffin slot", "mandi rate", "daily class streak" or "event vendor". If your main menu is full of words that no library draws, users get a mix of vague symbols. A designer draws one clear icon for each concept, in one style.

Your icons are part of your brand. On a food app, the category icons for thali, biryani, sweets and tea are large and often seen. They are close to illustrations. A library version makes your app look like every other food app. A custom set can use your brand's corner shape and colour.

You need to separate from a crowded category. In fintech, many apps use the same lock, shield and rupee symbols. A custom set will not fix trust by itself. But it can make a screen feel designed rather than assembled.

A custom set is also useful when users have low reading confidence. In a regional language app, a clear picture can carry the meaning when a long label does not fit. I write more about this in designing for regional language apps.

A middle path

You do not have to choose one side. A common and sensible approach is to use a library for the standard 20 to 30 icons and draw custom icons only for the 5 to 10 that are unique to your product. The custom icons must then match the library's stroke and corner style. This costs less and keeps the screen consistent.

Icon style consistency: four things that must match

When people say icons look "off", one of these four things is usually different.

  1. Stroke weight. The thickness of the line. If one icon has a 2 point line and another has 1.5, the eye notices at once.
  2. Corner style. Rounded ends and corners feel friendly. Sharp corners feel formal. Pick one.
  3. Fill style. Outline icons and filled icons should not sit side by side, except for a clear reason such as filled for the selected tab and outline for the others.
  4. Visual size. A circle and a square drawn at the same width do not look the same size. Round shapes need to be slightly larger. Good icon sets correct for this by eye.

Also keep the amount of detail equal. If the "orders" icon has six small parts and the "home" icon has two, they will look unequal even with the same stroke.

Grid, stroke and sizes

Every icon is drawn inside a square box called the artboard. Inside the box is a smaller area called the live area, where the main shape sits. The space between the live area and the edge is padding. Padding keeps icons from touching other elements and keeps them the same size in a row.

A simple setup that works for most apps:

ItemCommon choiceWhy
Artboard24 by 24 unitsStandard size for most interface icons
Padding2 units on each sideKeeps shapes from touching the edge
Stroke1.5 or 2 unitsOne value for the whole set
Corner radius1 to 2 units, or 0One value for the whole set
Larger sizes32 and 48 unitsFor empty screens and category tiles

Do not scale a 24 unit icon up to 48 and leave the stroke as it is, because the line becomes too thick or thin. Either scale the stroke too, or redraw the icon with its own stroke at the larger size.

For touch, remember that the icon is not the tap area. A 24 unit icon should sit inside a larger tap area, so a thumb on a mid-range Android phone can hit it. Accessibility guidance on tap targets is covered in my guide on accessibility in app and web design.

SVG icons: what to ask for

SVG means scalable vector graphic. It is a file that stores shapes as maths, so it stays sharp at any size and the file is small. That helps on slow networks. I cover that topic in designing for low-end phones and slow networks.

When you order or buy a set, ask for these:

  • One SVG file per icon, plus one file with the full set.
  • Strokes converted to outlines only if the developer asks for it. Otherwise keep strokes editable.
  • Icons named in plain lowercase words, such as cart, order-history, tiffin-slot.
  • Colour set by the developer in code, not fixed inside the file, so dark mode works.
  • A one page sheet showing every icon with its name and the grid used.

Dark mode matters here. If the colour is fixed inside the file, you will need a second set later. I explain the wider issue in the dark mode UI design guide.

How a custom set is made and priced

My process for an icon set is short. You send the list of icons and the screens where they appear. I suggest one style and draw two or three sample icons. After you approve the style, I draw the rest on the same grid. Then I export the SVG files and the overview sheet.

My custom icon price is ₹150 per icon, with a minimum order of 5 to 10 icons. A set usually takes 3 to 7 days, and two to three revision rounds are included. Prices elsewhere vary, because the cost depends on how detailed each icon is, how many are needed and how much of the style must be invented.

Before you decide, list your icons in three groups: standard, product specific and decorative. Use the library for the first group, pay for the second and think carefully about the third.

If you want a second opinion on which icons need drawing, I can look at your screens through icon and illustration design.

Frequently asked questions

Can I mix icons from two free icon libraries?

+

It is better not to. Each library has its own stroke weight, corner style and detail level, and mixing them makes the app look inconsistent. Pick one library and stay with it.

What size should app icons be?

+

Most interface icons are drawn on a 24 by 24 unit grid with about 2 units of padding, and a tap area larger than the icon itself. Use larger sizes such as 32 or 48 units for empty screens and category tiles.

What file format should I ask for with custom icons?

+

Ask for SVG files, one per icon, plus one overview sheet. SVG stays sharp at any size, keeps files small and lets developers change colour in code, which helps with dark mode.

Working on something like this?

Tell Tithi what you are planning. You get a clear scope, a fixed price and a timeline before any work begins. I reply to every enquiry within 24 hours.

Your details go only to Tithi and are used only to reply to you. No newsletters, no sharing.