Guide6 min readUpdated
Card Sorting for Website Menus: A Simple How-To Guide
Card sorting shows how your customers group pages, so you can organise a website menu and choose labels they understand. Run it with paper in one hour.
The owner of a coaching institute has 24 pages on her website. Her staff want the menu to follow the office departments: Academics, Admissions, Accounts, Administration. Parents search for "fees" and "batch timing" and cannot find them. The staff menu makes sense inside the office. It does not make sense to a parent.
Card sorting is a method where you write each page or topic on a card and ask people to put the cards into groups that feel natural to them. It helps with organising a website menu because it shows the groups your customers expect, in their words, not yours. It is one of the cheapest ways to improve information architecture, the structure behind your pages.
When do you need card sorting?
You need card sorting when your website has many pages, when your team disagrees about the menu, or when customers say they cannot find things. If your site has only 5 or 6 pages, you can skip it and use common sense.
Signs that a card sort will help:
- Your menu follows your company structure, not your customers' questions.
- Staff argue about which group a page belongs to.
- You have a "More" or "Others" item holding many pages.
- Visitors use search or call you for answers that are already on the site.
- You are adding a new service and do not know where it fits.
Card sorting also works for the menu of an app, such as the profile and settings area. For app navigation, see mobile app navigation patterns.
How do you run a card sort with paper?
Use paper cards, a table and one participant at a time. A first session takes about 20 to 30 minutes per person.
- List your pages. Write down every page or topic that needs a place in the menu. Aim for 20 to 40 items.
- Write one item per card. Use plain words, such as "Fee structure" or "Download brochure". Use one card for one idea.
- Remove the giveaways. Do not use words that already hint at a group, such as "Admissions: fees". Cards should stand alone.
- Shuffle the cards. Give them to the participant in a random order.
- Ask for piles. Say: "Put cards together that belong together in your mind. There are no right answers. Say your thoughts aloud as you go."
- Ask for names. When the piles are done, ask the person to write a name for each pile on a blank card.
- Take a photo. Photograph the final piles before you shuffle the cards again.
Do not explain what a card means unless the person is truly stuck. If they ask "What is this?", write down that the card was unclear. That confusion is useful, because a menu label can be unclear in the same way.
Should you use an open or a closed card sort?
Use an open sort when you are creating a menu, and a closed sort when you are checking a menu you already have. In an open sort, people make their own groups and names. In a closed sort, you give them the group names and they place each card under one.
| Open card sort | Closed card sort | |
|---|---|---|
| Group names | People invent them | You provide them |
| Best for | Planning a new menu | Testing an existing menu |
| What you learn | How people group and what they call things | Whether your names are clear |
| Risk | More work to read | People may force cards into a poor fit |
A good order is: run an open sort first, draw a new menu from the results, then run a short closed sort with 3 or 4 new people to check it.
How do you choose menu labels that people understand?
Choose labels from the words your customers used, not from your internal vocabulary. A menu label is the short text on each menu item, and it must tell a visitor what is behind it before they click.
Compare these examples for the coaching institute:
| Internal label | Customer wording | Better menu label |
|---|---|---|
| Accounts | "How much will it cost" | Fees |
| Academics | "What will my child study" | Courses |
| Admissions cell | "How do I join" | How to join |
| Notices | "Is there a holiday" | Updates |
Three rules help:
- Prefer one common word to a clever one. "Contact" beats "Let's connect".
- Avoid labels that could mean two things, such as "Resources".
- Keep labels short, so they fit on a small phone screen.
If your customers read Bengali or Hindi, run the sort in that language and note the words people write on the pile cards. They may use an English word in Bengali script for some items, such as "fees". Use the word they use. For a site in two languages, see Bengali and English bilingual website design.
How do you read the results of a card sort?
Look for cards that most people put together, and for cards that people place in many different groups. The first show you strong groups. The second show unclear items that need a better name or a place in two spots.
Make a simple table on a sheet or on the wall:
| Card | Group names people used | Agreement |
|---|---|---|
| Fee structure | Fees, Costs, Admission | High |
| Results | Courses, Success, About us | Low |
| Teacher profiles | About us, Faculty, Courses | Medium |
High agreement means put the card in that group. Low agreement means the item is unclear, or it deserves a link from two places. You do not need statistics. With 5 to 8 people, a clear pattern is visible by eye, and if no pattern appears, the cards may be too vague.
Pay attention to what people do not group. A card left alone often means a page that is not needed, or a page that has the wrong name.
Can you run card sorting without meeting people?
Yes. You can run it remotely with a spreadsheet or with a card sorting tool, and you can also use WhatsApp for a simple version. Send each person the list of items and ask them to reply with their groups and group names. Check the current features of any tool before you choose one.
Remote sorting reaches more people, but you lose the thinking aloud. Where you can, follow with a short call and ask: "Why did you put these together?"
Choose participants who match your customers. For the institute, that means parents and students, not teachers. People who know your business too well will copy your office structure.
How do you turn the groups into a menu?
Turn the strongest groups into your top-level menu items, and keep the number small. A menu with 4 to 6 top-level items is easier to scan than one with 10, especially on a phone.
Then:
- Name each group with the customer's wording.
- Put the most-visited group first, and "Contact" or the main button last.
- Place unclear pages in two spots if needed, rather than hiding them.
- Test the new menu with a few people by asking "Where would you look to find the fees?" and noting the first place they tap. This quick check is part of usability testing on a small budget.
Then give the menu a design, with spacing, tap size and a clear mobile version, as covered in website header and menu design. For a site with a small number of pages, the broader checklist is in the small business website design guide.
A designer can plan the groups, run the sort and draw the menu together as part of website design, and you are welcome to send me your page list to start.
Frequently asked questions
How many people do I need for a card sort?
+
Five to eight people from your real customer group is usually enough to see a pattern. If you see no pattern, change the cards or the group of people before adding more participants.
How many cards should I use?
+
Use 20 to 40 cards. Fewer cards give too little to sort, and more cards tire people and lower the quality of their groups.
Is card sorting only for websites?
+
No. It also works for app menus, settings screens, help centres and product categories in an online store.
What if people group the cards in very different ways?
+
Look for the groups that repeat across people, and accept that a few cards fit in two places. Add a clear search box and cross links for cards with low agreement.
Working on something like this?
Tell Tithi what you are planning. You get a clear scope, a fixed price and a timeline before any work begins. I reply to every enquiry within 24 hours.